zman’s Energy Brain

oil, gas, stocks, etc…

  • Blog Stats

    • 101,710 hits
  • Seeking Alpha Certified
  • Hello and Welcome - I’ve created this blog for the purpose of discussing energy related topics - primarily but not limited to oil and natural gas - and their potential impact on stocks, options, and futures. I am an amateur investor/trader and make no assurances about the opinions expressed on this blog. Please consult your financial advisor before buying, selling, borrowing, or otherwise risking capital based upon ideas taken from this site. Any advice construed from this website is worth what you paid me for it.
  • RSS Subscribe with a reader

  • Subscribe via RSS with

    Powered by FeedBurner

  • logo

Thursday – Opec, Gas Inventories

Posted by zmann on December 14, 2006

Opec Meets Today. And there are lots of mixed signals floating around:

Saudi – “The fundamentals of the market are much better than they were in October,” he said, adding: “We probably have a little work to do to make it an even better, more stable market.”

* – $60 oil seems fair to both sides

* Libya – “I don’t think there will be any cut,” the head of Libya’s delegation

* Iran – $70 oil and Israel must be wiped out

* Angola – glad to be a member, where’s the keg?

* Sudan & Ecuador – let us in, let us in!

The latest “official” word seems to be a 500,000 bopd cut delayed until Feb 1. Talk about less than zero. Oil is up around $1 on the news. This is the perfect announcement for the cartel. It sounds like you’re taking action but actually it’s just a threat of taking action if prices don’t hold $60.

Natural Gas Inventory Day: The First Of The Winter Withdrawals. Today we get the first of the 100 Bcf withdrawals from storage of the season. We scored 215 degrees last week, well above normal and year ago levels so there’s no way around a big number this morning. Of course, the forecast shows us tumbling all the way back to 144 this week (next week’s storage activity) and the week after that looks even warmer so any rally will be (should be) fleeting. Prime demand time is being wasted for much of the US.

Analyst Watch: VLO – buy to hold at Deutsche.

A word on gas well economics. People have said that gas will never go below $5 again because everything has changed in the gas industry since 1999 and poor E&P companies can’t drill a well for less than that. Put the cup down. Stop drinking the industries cool-aid. Here’s a recent, very common example of how wrong that is. Let’s take a shale well- lots of growth coming from those these days (CHK, DVN, EOG, APC, SWN etc, etc):

  • One Fayetteville Shales well – average reserves 1.5 Bcf – at $5 /Mcf held flat into the future the revenues off such a well would be $7.5 million.
  • SWN drills them for $2.2 million apiece.
  • This trend is less developed than its big brother the Barnett so it costs more to gather and process the gas and workers are more scare but these are hardly marginal economics — and that’s at $5 gas. Not the 12 months strip’s $8.
  • Yet this is what other big players in the industry are telling you. The play is not profitable for them and only marginally economic. Please. Cry me a river.

Recent Moves: Picked up a little APC 45 December put action on the suspicion that any commodity weakness will hurt these guys after the scathing comments from Goldman Sachs yesterday. Also bought SU 80 puts on the expectation of BRSN action regarding Opec and BHI 75s for same and the fact that the OIH looks overheated to me – what exactly is the catalyst for this recent move higher? I know it could easily pop into the high 150s but the service guys are starting to face some pricing pushback (something they haven’t seen in years). Finally, picked up the Jan 7.50 P s on EEE and am looking to pick up the long side of the trade (March 10 Calls) around year end.

Another word about oil. The following data is “unmassaged”, straight from the EIA. I download it and then put it in chart formats that are more user friendly than a line that begins at the beginning of time and runs to present. All in all, supplies are adequate if not plentiful. Given that Opec has excess supply and IEA just moderated its forecast for Chinese growth I’d call the present situation mildly bearish.

1) There is a lot of crude in storage at present…


2) … But more important is how much is in storage compared to other years at this time of the year. This is the same data stretched over 52 weeks of the year. Crude inventories are clearly above the mid point of the range.


3) Gasoline history – also relatively high just looking at a long term chart of gasoline


4) …but the 52 week chart reveals the impact of refinery outages. Gasoline inventories have made a relatively quick transition from somewhat oversupplied to somewhat under-supplied. Good for gasoline prices but not indicative of true supply and demand. Given the abundant supplies of crude on hand this situation can be quickly reversed once refineries decide to start operating again.


5) The long term Distillate history chart also shows relatively high stocks


6) But the 52 week chart shows the bounce off record (for that week in time) storage and the impact that low refinery utilization and secondary and tertiary demand has had.



17 Responses to “Thursday – Opec, Gas Inventories”

  1. zmann said

    CNBC says gas storage consensus is 159 bcf. That’s a pretty big number although last year Katrina shut ins caused it to swell to 206 and cold weather in 2002 forced a pull that week of 162. As Melissa Francis said, anything less than 159 and gas will sell off.

  2. gungagalonga said

    What did Maria B. say?

    -“Anything above 159 and we will be rationing gas all winter.”

    -Or, “anything between 159 and 161 will be 160”.

    -Or, “Anything below 159 and the rig count will plummet to zero, plus or minus 1,500”.

  3. zmann said

    you got it perfect. those are all direct quotes. you’d think these guys would be backing global cooling.

  4. zmann said


  5. zmann said

    168 vs 159 expectatioon. CNBC says very bullish, much bigger than expected. why, gas has already popped 10 cents on the number. wow. the analyst they had on made some good points about industrial consumption being a third of gas consumption and that the US manufacturing sector seems to be slowing and also that the weather is much warmer now and will be for the next 10 days. that we could see a reversal effect next week. the responses. “wow, a reversal effect” look of confusion. “we’ll have to have you back on next week.” too funny.

  6. walter said

    You were right Zman, OIH had no business going to 150!

  7. zmann said

    getting whiped this am on VLO despite downgrade and my brilliant opening position on BHI yesterday. SU running as well.

    Only APC not following the ya ya market ever higher. I’d like to see OIH fail off of 150 but it could just as easily go to 158.

    Opec statement in a hour

  8. zmann said

    SJT continues to fail without me. Too bad really but impossible to buy puts without getting scalped.

    BTU as a coal play on gas prices is acting miserably as well. Much more liquid market in its options.

  9. Attacking Mid said

    Has SU been halted? I’m showing no trades for about 15 minutes.


  10. zmann said

    Only if there’s a rule for halting stocks that are going up exponentially while I’m short them. Now that would be a good rule.

  11. Attacking Mid said

    IB’s system has been a bit flaky this morning. I locked up my desktop this am., and for some reason all is well here on my laptop after a hard reboot.

    Sorry to hear about your SU shorts. I had a few calls from yesterday which I sold for a decent profit this morning. I got filled on some of my Jan 80 put orders this morning. I may cancel the rest and try for the 85’s.

    I managed to get out of a huge (for me) CHK Dec call position. Took a small loss, but nothing like the situation I was in yesterday morning!

  12. zmann said

    I thought CNBC said the “much bigger than expected gas withdrawal” was “very bullish for natural gas”!!?! They’re hilarious. Gas is now down, I’m sure, despite “the much bigger than yada, yada, yada” Permabulls. Gotta love ’em

  13. zmann said

    APC breaking back below $46 – those $45Ps may actually work out.

  14. Jon said

    CHK just sits there but SWN is falling.

    I took OIH Jan 150s yesterday at 5.10 and got out today at 6.00. Thanks Tom2!

  15. zmann said

    Nice oil pump into the close.

    Gas closed down a dime on that uber bullish number.

    Stocks trading sideways going into close. XOI at all time high, XNG close, OIH could run annother 10 here no problem.

    Broader market sre rocketing higher and they’re buying everything with a ticker right now amongst the energy stocks except BTU and SJT. APC down a tad and looking lower but on the whole, a lousy day for the shorts.

  16. zmann said

    hey, my little CRR got a buy rating at Sidotti

  17. Funny a guy on Marketwatch mentioned that there was about 3Mbpd of spare capacity and that oil was at $40 when there was this much spare capacity.

    Oh yeah, things are you know, different now, yeah right.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: